city of tacoma
File #: ORD-27421    Version: 1 Name: Street Vacation
Type: Ordinance Status: Passed
File created: 1/10/2006 In control: City Council
On agenda: 1/10/2006 Final action: 1/10/2006
Title: Ordinance No. 27421
Attachments: 1. ORD-27421.pdf
Related files: RES40457
Date Ver.Action ByActionResultAction DetailsMeeting DetailsVideo
No records to display.
2 3 4 5 6 7 O"INANCE NO. 2 7 4 21 8 9 AN ORDINANCE vacating a portion of the alleyway between East 10 50th and East 51 st Streets, and a portion of East 51 st Street, more fully described as follows: That portion of the alleyway lying between Block 2 and 12 Block 3, together with the northerly 29.95 feet of East 51 st 13 Street abutting Block 3, all lands contained within the plat of THE CENTRAL PARK ADDITION TO TACOMA, filed 14 for record on January 31, 1889, in Volume 2, Page 1 1 1, records of Pierce County, Washington. 15 All lands contained within the Northeast Quarter of 16 Section 22, Township 20 North, Range 3 East, W.M. 1 7 WHEREAS all steps and proceedings required by law and by 18 resolution of the City Council to vacate the portion of the street 19 20 hereinafter named have been duly taken and performed; Now, 21 Therefore, 22 23 24 25 0rd10678.doc-KJC/bn Req.#10678 26 LEG 004 (11/89) 2 3 BE IT ORDAINED BY THE CITY OF TACOMA: 4 5 Section 1. That the City Council hereby adopts the Hearing 6 Examiner's Findings, Conclusions, and Recommendations as contained 7 in the Hearing Examiner's Report and Recommendation to the City 8 Council bearing File No. 124.1249, and dated August 31, 2005, which 9 Report is on file in the office of the City Clerk. 10 Section 2. That a portion of the alleyway between East 50th and I I 1 2 East 51 st Streets, and a portion of East 51 st Street, more fully described 13 as follows: 1 4 That portion of the alleyway lying between Block 2 and 1 5 Block 3, together with the northerly 29.95 feet of East 51 st Street abutting Block 3, all lands contained within the plat 1 6 of THE CENTRAL PARK ADDITION TO TACOMA, filed for record on January 31, 1889, in Volume 2, Page 1 1 1, 1 7 records of Pierce County, Washington. 18 All lands contained within the Northeast Quarter of 19 Section 22, Township 20 North, Range 3 East, W.M. 20 is hereby vacated, and the land so vacated is hereby surrendered 21 and attached to the property bordering thereon, respectively, as a 22 part thereof, and all right or title of the City in and to the portion of 23 24 25 0rd10678.doc-KJC/bn 2 Req.#10678 26 LEG 004 (11/89) 1 2 3 4 the streets so vacated does hereby vest in the owners of the 5 property abutting thereon, all in the manner provided by law. 6 Passed 7 !AN I 0 4Wt(A 8 Mayor 9 10 Attest: 12 City Clerk 13 14 Location: 1327 East 51st Street and 1329 East 51st Street Petitioner: Unique Construction, Inc. 15 Vacation Request No. 124.1249 16 17 Approved as to form and legality: Property description approved: 18 19 -Acting"Chie(,S@urveyor Assistant City Atigney 20 Public Works Department 21 22 23 24 25 Ord1O678.doc-KJC/bn 3 - Req.#10678 26 LEG 004 (11/89) CITY CLERK USE REQUEST FOR O"INANCE Request Tacoma OR RESOLUTION Ordinance F 0 Resolution nf% 1"05 SEP 2 2 AM 9: 3 1 I - DATE: September 22, 2005 LI iY C IL E R ii" -3) OrUICE 2 . REQUESTING DEPARTMENT/DIVISION/PROGRAM 3. CONTACT PERSON (for questions): PHONE/EXTENSION Hearing Examiner Louisa Legg 5195 4. PREPARATION OF AN ORDINANCE IS REQUESTED FOR THE CITY COUNCIL MEETING OF TUESDAY, OCTOBER 18,2005. 5. SUMMARY TITLE/RECOMMENDATION: (A concise sentence, as it will appear on the Council agenda.) Petitioner: Unique Construction File No: 124.1249 The petitioner is seeking to vacate that portion of the alleyway between East 50t" and East 5 l't Street, and a portion of East 5 I't Street in Tacoma. LOCATION: 1327 East 5 1 " Street and 1329 East 5 Is' Street 6. BACKGROUND INFORMATION/GENERAL DISCUSSION: (Why is this request necessary? Are there legal requirements? What are the viable alternatives? Who has been involved in the process?) 7. FINANCIAL IMPACT: A. FX@ N 0 B. F-@ YES OVER$ 1 00,000, Fiscal Note Attached C. YES, UNDER $100,000, Provide funding source information below FUNDING SOURCE: (Enter amount of funding from each source) Fund Number & Name: State $ City $ Other $ Total Amount If an expenditure, is it budgeted? r-1 Yes F-1 No Where? Cost Center: Acet #: 8. LIST ALL MATERIAL AVAILABLE AS BACKUP INFORMATION FOR THE REQUEST AND INDICATE WHERE FILED: Source Documents/Backup Material Location of Document ? Hearing Examiner Report and Recommendation m Attached ? Departmental (Asset Management) Preliminary Report 0 Attached 9. ATTORNEY CONTACT: (Enter name of attorney with whom you've been working.) I 0. Department Director/Utifity Division Approval OMBA/Finance Director Approv )iree roval GSWebMg,lDocimews, Office of the City Clerk (5104) 27421 C/ Tacoma City of Ibcoma Hearing Examiner August 31, 2005 Mr. Bill Relic Unique Construction, Inc. 2316 891h Street Ct. SW Gig Harbor WA 98332 Re: Unique Construction File No.: 124.1249 Street Vacation Petition File Nos.: 40000046586 ("Rehe Plat" Preliminary Plat) and 40000047426 (Variance) Enclosed please find a copy of the Hearing Examiner's Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law, and Recommendation (124.1249) and Decisions (40000046586 and 40000047426) with regard to the above-referenced matters as a result of a public hearing held August 16, 2005. RODNEY M. KERSLAKE Hearing Examiner /Ial Enclosures (2) Cc: See attached mailing list 747 Market Stre(,t. Room 720 1 Tacoma. Washington 98402-3768 1 (253) 591-5195 1 Fax (253) 591-2003 MAILING LIST: BILL REHE, UNIQUE CONSTRUCTION FILE NOS. 124.1249; 40000046586; AND 40000047426 Cc: David Schroedel, AHBL, Inc., 2215 North 301h Street, STE 300, Tacoma WA 98403 Robert Denomy, Attorney at Law, 950 Pacific Avenue, STE 630, Tacoma WA 98402 Lloyd and Dolores Hamilton, 1315 E. 52dStreet, Tacoma WA 98404-2712 Charlene Hill, 5011 E. "L" Street, Tacoma WA 98404-3627 Scott Hansen, President, Puget Creek Restoration Society, 702 Broadway, Suite IO 1, Tacoma, WA 98402 Sandra Collins, 1214 E. 50'h Street Tacoma WA 98406-3633 James Conlin, 1307 E. 52dStreet, Tacoma WA 98404-2712 Ann Crawford, 1401 E. 52 dStreet Tacoma WA 98404-2739 Rose Jones, 1216 E 501h Street, Tacoma WA 98404-3633 City Clerk (Clerk's Jacket 124.1249), City of Tacoma Legal Department (Civil Division), City of Tacoma (Molly Schmidt) Department of Public Works, City of Tacoma (Env. Svcs. Eng./Ryan Flynn) Department of Public Works, City of Tacoma (Solid Waste Mgmt./R. Coyne) Department of Public Works, City of Tacoma (Construction/LID/S. Simpson) Department of Public Works, City of Tacoma (LUA/P. Katich) Department of Public Works, City of Tacoma (BLUS/T. Dolan) Department of Public Works, City of Tacoma (BLUS/Jennifer Hansen) Department of Public Works, City of Tacoma (BLUS/Susan Coffinan) Department of Public Works, City of Tacoma (BLUS/Andrea Gates Department of Public Works, City of Tacoma (Traffic Engineering/Kurtis Kingsolver) General Services Department, Asset Management, City of Tacoma (Rich Price) Tacoma Fire Department, City of Tacoma (Carl Anderson) Tacoma Power, City of Tacoma (New Svcs. Eng./Nick Tomanelli) Tacoma Water, City of Tacoma (Grant Whitley) TEDD, City of Tacoma (L. Wung) Pierce County Assessor-Treasurer, ATTN: Sally Bames, 2401 South 35th St., Room 142, Tacoma, WA 98409 Tacoma-Pierce County Health Department, ATTN: Nedda S. Turner, R.S., Env. Source Protection Liason, 3629 South D Street, Tacoma, WA 98418-6813 C OFFICE OF THE HEARING EXAMINER CITY OF TACOMA REPORT AND RECOMMENDATION TO THE CITY COUNCIL PETITIONER: Bill Rehe, Unique Construction FILE NO: 124.1249 SUMMARY OF REQUES : A petition to vacate a portion of the alleyway between East 50th and East 5l't Streets and a portion of East 5 1 " Street, in Tacoma RECOMMENDATION OF THE HEARING EXAMINER: The request is hereby recommended for approval, subject to conditions. PUBLIC HEARING: After reviewing the report of the General Services Department, Asset Management Division, examining available infortuation on file with the application, and visiting the subject site and the surrounding area, the Hearing Examiner conducted a public hearing on the application on August 16, 2005. FINDINGS, CONCLUSIONS, AND RECOMMENDATION: FINDINGS: 1. Bill Rehe, Unique Construction (hereinafter "petitioner") is requesting the vacation of the alley right-of-way lying westerly of East "N" Street and situated between East 50'h and East 5 I't Streets and terminating at the west boundary of THE CENTRAL PARK ADDITION TO TACOMA. Also being requested for vacation is the northerly 29.95 feet of East 5 l't Street lying westerly of East "N' Street and terminating at the west boundary of the earlier referred-to plat. The rights-of-way here sought to be vacated are more particularly described below: That portion of the alleyway lying between Block 2 and Block 3; together with the northerly 29.95 feet of East 5 I't Street abutting Block 3, all lands contained within the plat of THE CENTRAL PARK ADDITION TO TACOMA, filed for record on January 31, 1889 in Volume 2 Page I I 1, records of Pierce County, Washington. All lands contained within the Northeast Quarter of Section 22, Township 20 North, Range 3 East, W.M. 2. The petitioner is proposing to subdivide 6.35 acres of property lying westerly of the subject rights-of-way into 34 single-family building lots. The rights-of-way, if vacated, would be incorporated into the subdivision site. 3. The rights-of-way were dedicated for public street and alley purposes when the plat of THE CENTRAL PARK ADDITION TO TACOMA was filed for record on January 31,1889. 4. Both of the rights-of-way in question are undeveloped and have not been used for street or alley purposes in spite of being dedicated for public use for over 1 15 years. 5. The subject alleyway is 20 feet in width and extends approximately 80 feet west of East "N" Street and terminates at the west boundary of THE CENTRAL PARK ADDITION TO TACOMA. East 5 I't Street is a 70-foot wide right-of-way and also extends east of East "N' Street approximately 80 feet and ends at the west line of the referred-to plat boundary. If the vacation of the north 29.95 feet East 5 I't Street granted, slightly over 40 feet of right-of-way width would remain. 6. Allownersofpropertyabuttingthesubjectrights-of-wayhavejoinedinthepetition seeking their vacation. 7. The vacation petition has been reviewed by a number of governinental agencies and utility providers. None objects to their vacation; however, the Department of Public Works advises that an "In-Lieu-of-Assessment Charge" is owing for the rights-of-way, if vacated, and Asset Management advises that the petitioner is required to compensate the City in the amount of the appraised value of the rights-of-way. FINDINGS, CONCLUSIONS, AND RECOMMENDATION - 2 - 15. Since the rights-of-way are not proximate to a body of water, the provisions of RCW 35.79.035 are not implicated. 16. Pursuant to WAC 197-11-800(2)(h), the vacation of streets or roads is exempt from the threshold detennination and Environniental Impact Statement requirements of RCW43.2l.C, the State Environmental Policy Act (SEPA). 17. The Asset Management Preliminary Report, as entered into this record as Exhibit 6, accurately describes the proposed project, general and specific facts about the site and area, and applicable codes. The report is incorporated herein by reference as though fully set forth. 18. All property owners of record and adjacent to the proposed vacation have been notified of the hearing date at least 30 days prior to the hearing, as required by TMC 9.22.060. 19. Any conclusion hereinafter stated which may be deemed to be a finding herein is hereby adopted as such. CONCLUSIONS: 1. ThcHearingExaminerhasjurisdictionoverthepartiesandsubjectmatterinthis proceeding. See TMC 1.23.050.A.5 and TMC 9.22. 2. Proceedings involved in the consideration of petitions for the vacation of public rights-of-way are quasi judicial in nature. State v. City ofSpokane, 70 Wn.2d 207, 442 P.2d 790 (1967). 3. Petitions for the vacation of public right-of-way are reviewed for consistency with the following criteria: 1. The vacation will provide a public benefit, and/or will be for public purpose. 2. That the right-of-way vacation shall not adversely affect the street pattern or circulation of the immediate area or the community as a whole. 3. That the public need shall not be adversely affected. 4. That the right-of-way is not contemplated or needed for future public use. 5. That no abuttin owner becomes land-locked or his access will not be 9 substantially impaired; i.e., there must be an alternative mode of ingress and egress, even if less convenient. FINDINGS, CONCLUSIONS, AND RECOMMENDATION - 4 - GRANTED AND IS A CONTINUING REQUIREMENT OF SUCH APPROVALS. BY ACCEPTING THIS/THESE APPROVALS, THE PETITIONER REPRESENTS THAT THE DEVELOPMENT AND ACTIVITIES ALLOWED WILL COMPLY WITH SUCH LAWS, REGULATIONS, AND ORDINANCES. IF, DURING THE TERM OF THE APPROVAL GRANTED, THE DEVELOPMENT AND ACTIVITIES PERMITTED DO NOT COMPLY WITH SUCH LAWS, REGULATIONS, OR ORDINANCES, THE PETITIONER AGREES TO PROMPTLY BRING SUCH DEVELOPMENT OR ACTIVITIES INTO COMPLIANCE. 7. Any finding hereinbefore stated which may be deemed to be a conclusion herein is hereby adopted as such. RECOMMENDATION: The vacation request is hereby recommended for approval, subject to conditions contained in Conclusion 6. DATED this 3 Is' day of August, 2005. RODNEY M. KERSLAKE, Hearing Examiner FINDINGS, CONCLUSIONS, AND RECOMMENDATION - 6 - PRELIMINARY "PORT PREPARED FOR THE HEARING EXAMINER BY ASSET MANAGEMENT For the Hearing to be Held Tuesday, August 16, 2005 at 1:30 PM PETITIONER: UNIQUE CONSTRUCTION, INC FILE NO. 124.1249 A. SUMMARY OF REQUEST: Asset Management has received a petition to vacate that portion of the alleyway between East 501h and East 5 1 " Streets, and a portion of East 5 I't Street, as shown on the attached vicinity map. B. GENERAL INFORMATION: 1. Legal Description of Vacation: That portion of the alleyway lying between Block 2 and Block 3; together with the northerly 29.95 feet of East 5 1 " Street abutting Block 3, all lands contained within the plat of THE CENTRAL PARK ADDITION TO TACOMA, filed for record on January 3 1, 1889 in Volume 2, Page I I 1, records of Pierce County, Washington. All lands contained within the Northeast Quarter of Section 22, Township 20 North, Range 3 East, W.M. 2. Notification: 9.22.060 NOTICE OF PLTBLIC HEARING The General Services Department shall cause a 30-day notice to be given of the pendency of the petition by written notice posted in three of the most public places in the City, a like notice in a conspicuous place on the street or alley sought to be vacated, a like notice in a newspaper of general circulation in the City, and a like notice to the legal property owners of all property abutting the right of way requested for vacation as enumerated on the applicant's vacation petition, and to any other interested parties of record. In addition to posting notices of the hearing, the General Services Department shall mail a copy of the notice to all owners and occupants of the property which lies within 300 feet of the street or alley to be vacated. The said notice shall contain the statement that a petition has been filed to vacated the street or alley described in the notice, together with a statement that a petition has been filed to vacate the street or alley described in the notice, together with a statement of the time and place fixed for the hearing of the petition. In all cases where the proceeding is initiated by the City Council without a petition having been signed by the owners of more than two-thirds of the JAReal Estate & Right of Way\Street Vacations\Active Vacations\124.1249 - Unique ConstructionTreliminary Report.doc7/22/99 Page I of 4 property abutting upon the part of the street or alley sought to be vacated, notice shall be sent as provided above. Failure to send notice by mail to any such property owner where the current address for such property owner is not a matter of public record shall not invalidate any proceedings in connection with the proposed street vacation. C. PURPOSE OF REQUEST: The petitioner plans to combine vacated right of way into adjoining property for the purpose of creating additional residential units under a preliminary plat " Rehe Plat". D. HISTORY: The City of Tacoma acquired the rights of way proposed to be vacated when the plat of THE CENTRAL PARK ADDITION TO TACOMA, filed for record on January 31,1889 in Volume 2, Page I I 1, records of Pierce County, Washington. E. PHYSICAL LAND CHARACTERISTICS: The vacation area is unimproved and largely overground with trees and shrubs. This area has not been improved with street improvements the right of way width of East N Street is 60 feet in width. East 5oth Street and East 5 I't Streets are 70 feet in width. F. APPLICABLE SECTIONS OF THE OFFICIAL CODE OF THE CITY OF TACOMA: 9.22.01 0 PETITION TO VACATE AUTHORIZED: The owners of an interest in any real estate abutting on any street or alley who may desire to vacate any street or alley, or any part thereof, shall petition to the City Council to make vacation in the manner hereafter provided in this chapter and pursuant to RCW 35.79 or the City Council may itself initiate by Resolution such vacation procedure. The City Council shall require the petitioners to compensate the City in an amount which equals one-half of the appraisal value of the area vacated; provided that if the street or alley has been a public right of way for 25 years or more, the City shall be compensated in an amount equal to the full appraised value of the area vacated; provided that when the vacation is initiated by the City or the City Council deems it to be in the best interest of the City, all or any portion of such compensation may be waived. Except as provided below, one-half of the revenue received hereunder shall be devoted to the acquisition, improvement, and maintenance of public open space land and one-half may be devoted to transportation projects and the management and maintenance of other City owned lands and unimproved rights-of-way. In the case of vacations of rights-of-way in the tide flats area, defined as easterly of the Thea Foss Waterway (inclusive of the Murray Morgan Bridge), northerly of State Route 509 and westerly of Marine View Drive, the total revenue received hereunder shall be devoted to transportation projects in the tide flats area. N JAReal Estate & Right of Way\Street Vacations\Active Vacations\124.1249 - Unique ConstructionTreliminary Report.doc7/22/99 Page 2 of4 9.22.040 PUBLIC'S RIGHT TO TRAVEL - UTILITIES: Vacation of any portion of a street that is designated as an arterial under Section 1 1.05.490 of the Municipal Code shall be of a minor nature only and shall not unreasonably limit the public's right to travel upon said street or interfere with the ancillary right to occupy said street for utility purposes. CRITERIA: Section 9.22.070 of the Official Code of the City of Tacoma. The following criteria have been considered: 1 .That the vacation will provide a public benefit and/or will be for a public purpose. 2. That the right-of-way vacation shall not adversely affect the street pattern or circulation of the immediate area or the community as a whole. 3. That the public need shall not be adversely affected. 4. That the right-of-way is not contemplated or needed for future public use. 5. That no abutting owner becomes landlocked or his access will not be substantially impaired; i.e., there must be an alternative mode of ingress and egress, even if less convenient. 6. That vacation of right-of-way shall not be in violation of RCW 35.79.035 G. ADDITIONAL INFORMATION: The area to be vacated has not been assessed for sanitary sewers and is subject to a Connection Charge In-Licu-of-Assessment per T.M.C. 12.08.350. Should the petitioner wish to clear this item from title, please contact Sue Simpson of the Public Works Department, L.I.D. Section, at 591-5529 for the assessment amount. Please note that the ordinance establishing the rate of assessment is updated every few years, and the amount quoted may increase in the future. When the petitioner has submitted a development plan, an in lieu of amount will be computed. H. PROJECT RECOMMENDATIONS: As part of the City's review process for street vacation petitions, notice of this application was mailed to various City departments as well as many outside quasi-governmental agencies. These agencies, as noted below, have provided comments and recommended conditions to the Asset Management Division. These comments, where appropriate, have been incorporated in the "Recommended Conditions of Approval" section of this preliminary report. JAReal Estate & Right of Way\Street Vacations\Active Vacations\124.1249 - Unique ConstructionTreliminmy Report.doc7/22/99 Page 3 of 4 PW/Construction/LID - No objections Tacoma Water - No objections Environmental Services - No objections Puget Sound Energy - No objections TEDD - No objections Tacoma Fire Department- No objection Comcast Communications - No objections Traffic Engineering - No objections Pierce Transit - No objections Solid Wast Mgt. - No objections 1. RECOMMENDED CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL: Should this street vacation request be approved, the Asset Management Division recommends that the following conditions be made conditions of approval for this street vacation petition. I . PAYMENT OF FEES The petitioner shall compensate the City in an amount equal to the full appraised value of the area vacated. One-half of the revenue received shall be devoted to the acquisition, improvement and maintenance of public open space land and one-half may be devoted to transportation projects and /or management and maintenance of other City owned lands andunimprovedrights-of-way. TMC9.22.010 2. BUILDING AND LAND USE SERVICES No objections subject to the following condition: The applicant shall comply with all City regulations for any ftiture use of the subject site. ATTACHMENT: Vacation Jacket containing all pertinent maps and papers. JAReal Estate & Right of Way\Street Vacations\Active Vacations\124.1249 - Unique ConstructionTreliminary Report.doc7/22/99 Page 4 of 4 320221001 A30 0 26 4# 1 020170 - 0 on@ 64V 0 8 M ------------- ST50TH 03 21 C 2Y: 30 2T 65 G16 0 A C4 14 ::75: 16 5500056@. 6 .9 o 0320222016 4: 1,5 2 6.5*0 24 41 :!2965000550 29654057 EAST 51 ST STRE ET 051 0320222090 5 OK UNIQUE CONSTRUCTION, INC STREET VACATION NO. 124.1249 EAST 51 ST STREET I EAST N STREET NE114 SEC.22, T20N, R3E NOT TO SCALE - - I I @,_ CITY OF TACOMA 0 0 5 0 E C 2 2 A M 9: 34 INTER-DEPARTMENTAL COMMUNICATION @@ ill @-Z" U_Lt it OFFICE TO: Doris Sorum, City Clerk U vxhA, Mary Shirley, Office Assistant/Amy Stevenson-Ness FROM: Kyle J. Crews, Assistant City Attorney DATE: December 20, 2005 SUBJECT: Street Vacation File No. 124.1249 Applicant: Unique Construction Please place Ordinance No. 27421 on the Council agenda of January 10, 2006, for second reading. Asset Management will cover the second reading. As of the date of this memo, the jacket is located in the Legal Department. /mds cc: Louisa Legg, Hearing Examiner's Office Jodi Marshall, Hearing Examiner's Office Rich Price, General Services, Asset Management fAord\forms\2ndvac.doc CITY OF TACOMA INTER-DEPARTMENTAL COMMUNICATION TO: Doris Sorum, City Clerk Mary Shirley, Office Assistant/Amy Stevenson-Ness FROM: Kyle J. Crews, Assistant City Attorney DATE: December 20, 2005 SUBJECT: Street Vacation File No. 124.1249 Applicant: Unique Construction Please place Ordinance No. 27421 on the Council agenda of January 10, 2006, for second reading. Asset Management will cover the second reading. As of the date of this memo, the jacket is located in the Legal Department. /mds cc: Louisa Legg, Hearing Examiner's Office Jodi Marshall, Hearing Examiner's Office Rich Price, General Services, Asset Management fAord\forms\2ndvac.doc Tacoma City of Tacoma Et r@n Memorandum ""%WC I VI: U DEC I 3 2005 TACOMA CITY ATTORNEY CIVIL DIVISION TO: KYLE CREWS ASSISTANT CITY ATTORNEY FROM: RICHARD PRICE Asset Management Division General Services Department SUBJECT: RIGHT OF WAY VACATION NO. 124.1249 ORDINANCE NO. 27421 DATE: DECEMBER 13,2005 All conditions for the referenced right of way vacation have been met. This ordinance may be placed on the Council Agenda for final reading. Please schedule the 2 d Reading for January 10, 2006. Asset Management will cover the reading. JAReal Estate & Right of Way\Street Vacations\Active Vacations\124.1249 - Unique Construction\Attorney Memo.doc7/23/99 Ordinance No. 27421 First Reading of Ordinance: OCT 1 8 2005 Final Reading of Ordinance:'JAN I 0 MS Passed: 41A .2006 Roll Call Vote: MEMBERS AYES NAYS ABSTAIN AB Siff N-T Ms. Anderson Mr.Evans Ms. Ladenburg Mr. Lonergan Mr. Manthou Mr. Pb4gps@ Mr. Stenger Mr. Talbert [Mayor Baarsma MEMBERS AYES NAYS ABSTAIN ABSENT Ms. Anderson Mr.Evans Mr. Ladenburg Mr. Lonergan Mr. Manthou Mr. Talbert Mayor Baarsma 9:lcitYclklcitYclk@forms@ord-roll.doc